Russet No More

Specializing in monoculture and importation, the US is not exactly a cornucopia of natural biodiversity. The value of biodiversity is significant for numerous reasons-  balance in an ecosystem, aesthetic values, economic reasons, ethical values, to find cures for ailments, the list goes on and on and the examples are endless. One more reason is that it makes life far more interesting and less predictable, particularly when it comes to dinner. How boring is it that corn is white or yellow? Grapes are green or purple. And cows are milk or meat. I yearn for the fall when instead of buying “red” or “green” apples you can choose from Pink Ladies, Fiji, Macintosh, Mutsu… the list goes on and on. Biodiversity is not just beneficial for ecosystem balance and ethical reasons, but I also like to have more than beef and Russet potatoes for dinner.

But one of the amazing things about Chiloé is that if you do decide to have beef for dinner (Rather than milcaos, curantos, shellfish, mollusks, cordero, crab, oh so many things to choose from!) the island is native to over two hundred types of potatoes. Over 230 varieties are identified on the archipelago of Chiloé, and in all of Chile there are over five hundred varieties of potatoes. However, it is true that market forces still come into effect and it may be difficult to choose from the same diversity from long ago as only a handful of species are highly commercialized. However, in the produce market of Castro it is still possible to find at least ten varieties, many of which are still exciting and “exotic”. There are purple potatoes, blue potatoes, pink potatoes, polka-dotted potatoes, and even potatoes that taste like artichokes. The Universidad Austral de Chile maintains a gene bank and information on potato varieties on the island and in the mainland, playing a vital role to the preservation of the biodiversity of this important crop.

By one estimate there are over 10,000 producers of papas on the archipelago of Chiloe; the producers of potatoes are essentially all small farms, on many of the smaller islands. Within the past several decades there has been a decrease in the number of potato production, which is speculated to be partly attributed to a decrease in the available labor because of an increase in the salmon industry. Whereas the local produce market sells more types of potatoes than you will ever find outside of bag of potato chips in an American supermarket, there are still only a handful of sellers in the local market. Like the majority of crops in Chile, the best quality and a largest quantity is exported.

Genes from native Chilote potatoes can be found all over the world. During the potato famine in the 1840s and 1850s scientists came from abroad to Latin America and Chiloe to search for new strands of potatoes, proving at least once in history the vital role of this important source of biodiversity. It is truly remarkable that a food crop as prevalent and invariable worldwide as the potato has greater genetic variability in a place just larger than Rhode Island. Whereas many people get pleasure from knowing that more varieties other than the Russet species exist just in case, it is also pleasurable to aprovechar and experience the variety that natural biodiversity offers. Have you ever tried a potato that tastes like an artichoke?


The Saturday market in Castro offers an array of fresh produce, much of which is grown on the island. Although there are more than 200 varieties from Chiloe, relatively few are available in the market throughout the year.


Although potatoes are one of the principal crops grown on the island, the majority is exported. Still, there are many different varieties of potatoes for sale in the market that come in a variety of colors, shapes and sizes. One even tastes like an artichoke.



Potato farming near the town of Puqueldón. The total yield of potatoes has decreased in recent years. Sometimes the growth of the farmed salmon industry is cited as a cause.


A plate of beef with native potatoes, from the restaurant Un Buen Amigo in Castro. Served with a chocolate mousse for dessert, I paid CHP 2.200, which is less than $4.50. Sooooooo delicious, one MUST take advantage of the cuisine when visiting Chiloe. 

Cuidado con el Sol!

It feels like it is a lot easier to find SPH 75 in Chile than an SPF less than 10, which is good news because twenty minutes in the afternoon and I am cooked. Along some beaches and public spaces there are advisory warnings for the strength of the sun, but many times they do not work or display the highest possible warning.
Unfortunately, that is probably not so much because there is greater concern for the skin as it is the sun is fierce. Whereas one would think that there is greater risk of skin cancer towards the south where the ozone hole extends, the rates of cancer are actually greatest in regions II (Antofogasta, the north), V (Valparaíso or Santiago to the ocean), and the Metropolitan Region (Santiago). In recent years, the amount of cases of skin cancer in Chile has more than doubled.

But in the southernmost regions of Chile one still has to be more careful. The National Corporation of Cancer, CONAC, warned that with a 1.2% decreased density of ozone within the same period two years ago, there is an estimated increased risk of 3- 4.5% of skin cancer. The springtime (or northern hemisphere fall), is when sunlight begins to shine in Antarctica and initiate catalytic ozone destruction, which makes it the most dangerous times in terms of ozone destruction. One can find daily UV warnings using the website http://www.indiceuv.cl/. Or you can safely assume that the sun is dangerous, particularly between 11:00 and 16:00, and always use sun protection.


A "SOLMAFORO" on the beach in Dichato that does not function. "Solmaforo" is a play on words, as 'Sol' = Sun and 'Semáforo' = stoplight. 
 


Alerts with the maximum amount of time one can be in the sun's exposure depending on skin color with suggestions. I burn much faster in Chile than in the US and need much more sun protection. 



Protect yourself from the sun. Although the ozone hole is in the south of the country, Santiago, has one of the highest rates of skin cancer, as well as Valparaíso and Arica, a city in the north. 

Flirting with Nuclear Ideas

To many people, considering a nuclear power plant in Chile, one of the most seismic countries in the world, seems like a not-so-smart idea. However, the Chilean Ministry of Energy is not as quick to denounce the idea 100%, as well as a couple Chileans I have met. I think the bottom line is that if energy demand continues to increase around 5% every year for the next several decades, hydropower and non-conventional renewable many not be sufficient enough in 20-30 years. Nuclear power has the benefit that it produces greater energy per area, would not alter the environment in the same ways as hydropower, emits relatively few greenhouse gases in its production, and may be economically feasible in the long run. Thus, the danger of being by a major fault line is minimized…  

Some say a nuclear power plant in the north would be the best location because it is close to the sea for water, close to the mountains (for waste disposal), far from the largest concentration of the Chilean population (but closer to Peru and Bolivia) and distant from the major earthquakes characteristic of the south. However, the north also lies near a fault and has also experienced earthquakes over 8.0, just not in as recent history. Although it seems more practical than the central Chile (close to Santiago) or the south where there has been more recorded large earthquakes and tsunamis, it is still not ideal.

The Ministry of Energy also seems to have faith that the problems encountered in Japan will enhance technology for nuclear power plants in seismic areas, in the end benefitting Chile. However, even if the highest officials swear on the safety of nuclear power, I am highly doubtful that the general population would ever support the idea. There is profound distrust in the Chilean state, and common sense will tell people that there will always be a risk. Part of the problem is the control- how to stop a nuclear leak, advising the population if there is one, and properly attending to the problem. I do not predict a nuclear power plant in the distant future, I think by the time Chile were ready there would be an alternative solution. But if it were up to the Ministry of Energy I believe that they would try to find a reason to debunk any doubts against constructing a nuclear power plant. There would be intense opposition to the plant because of the environmental and societal risk, distrusting (with reason) officials that propone it as well as any future workers of the plant.

An additional impediment to building a nuclear power plant is that Chile has very few nuclear scientists. For a country concerned about energy security and independence, there is a shortage of nuclear engineers.

In essence, nuclear power in Chile seems pretty bogus and unrealistic for present times… but the idea will continue to be flirted around for many years.   

Energy Security vs. Environmental Quality

One of the most prominent environmental issues in Chile is, without question, that of energy security. With three-quarters of the energy consumed imported, price volatility and intervention of the energy supply are real concerns faced by past, present and future administrations. The Ministry of Energy predicts that if energy demands increase by 4.6% each year, energy needs will double by 2023 and triple by 2032. Among administrations it is the general understanding that cheap and plentiful energy is key to development and a higher standard of living. However at the same time many Chileans place a high value on environmental quality; according to the World Values Survey of 2006, approximately 67% of Chileans indicated that they preferred “to take care of the environment” over “economic growth and the creation of jobs,” which earned 31% of the vote. Obviously in part for this reason it is expected that energy projects will be delayed due to opposition from environmental organizations and the general public.

And without a doubt Chileans have precious lands that are vulnerable to exploitation and degradation. From dams in Patagonia to the wind farms in Chiloe, solar panels in Antofogasta or a nuclear power plant in the north, (hundreds of) tentative and real projects abound to reduce energy dependence and/or increase energy supply.

Many officials warn of an energy crisis in Chile’s future, rhetoric which becomes especially frantic if hydroelectric power, particularly the HydroAysin projects, are not fully exploited. As the primary source of energy produced in Chile, and emitting relatively little greenhouse gases in comparison with fossil fuels, hydroelectric power is often the preferred energy source of policy makers, regardless of the irreversible environmental degradation it causes.

But despite all the projects to increase the energy supply produced in Chile, especially for Santiago, there exists extreme wastefulness without any significant effort to reduce it. Green building ideas are virtually inexistent. Houses and buildings are not insulated, low-flush toilets do not exist, water-saving shower heads are not used, windows are not sealed, practically the only green building appliances in use are higher efficiency light bulbs. Billions of dollars are invested into generating more energy, dozens of commissions exist to analyze these situations, but hardly any resources are invested into energy efficiency. As the saying goes, “a penny saved is a penny earned.” Similarly, a kwh saved is a kwh gained. Yeah, yeah, yeah- little things do not make much of a difference, it is the big changes that count… but what if Santiago and Chile in general were to put as much effort into ensuring energy efficiency as it is being put into constructing five dams at an estimated price of US $3.2 billion? Could that make a difference?

It is one thing if a country tries to secure safe and sufficient energy at a reasonable price, but to severely degrade the natural environment- PATAGONIA (!!!) included- without first eliminating wastefulness is irresponsible and unforgivable.       

More than "Think Global, Act Local..."

As a global studies and environmental studies major, I have been told on several occasions in each discipline to “Think Global, Act Local.” To take action in my own community so as to benefit the global community at large. Whereas I fully support local initiatives to take care of the environment in the places that we live, it is also fundamentally important to understand perspectives and challenges from beyond your own backyard. As a student at University of California Santa Barbara, there are struggles and initiatives all around to improve the quality of the environment. Be it increasing the recycling rates, restoring watersheds to native vegetation to improve the quality of water that reaches the ocean, educating the youth on the importance of conservation, using low energy appliances, the list is endless. But Santa Barbara is a very environmentally conscious community (with relatively significant resources, in comparison to the US and abroad) and it still faces many environmental challenges. Certainly the problems faced in the United States and Santa Barbara are not necessarily encountered as priorities elsewhere. An experience living abroad makes one “think global” much more literally, but once abroad, viewing the world from a local perspective will assist in understanding the cultural, economic and technical boundaries that contribute to many local challenges, such as environmental degradation. Thus one must not take for granted that it is also important to “Think Local.”

Living and studying abroad will doubtlessly alter one’s perspective, and is often an invaluable experience to developing worldviews. But it may also be an economic stress on many families, which is why it is important for students interested in studying abroad to research and pursue potential scholarship and financial aid options. The Benjamin A.Gilman International Scholarship is available to many low-income college and university students that are United States citizens. If you are a university student interested in studying abroad- which in my personal opinion I highly recommend- it is definitely worth applying for if you qualify. Any sincere interest studying abroad should not be hindered by one’s economic situation until all financial aid and scholarship options are exhausted. So please, if you are a college or university student interested in studying abroad, check out the Gilman Scholarship website and “Go Global.”



34 recycling programs for 34 municipalities...

Recycling barely exists in Santiago, and even less so in Chile. Yes, the culture and habit to separate trash for recycling does not exist for a large portion of the population. But my biggest frustration is that even if I want to make the effort to recycle, living in Providencia (in a building of ~800 people, nonetheless), there are literally no options to recycle anything other than glass, newspapers, old books and batteries- unless I bring my recyclables to one of the university campuses, urban parks, or public buildings that have separate receptacles for recycling. But looking closely there are several separate initiatives and recycling projects within the city- the Punto Limpio in Vitacura, recycling pick-up in Ñuñoa Recicla, the Coca-Cola or EcoChilectra pilot programs in Peñalolén, vermicultura in La Pintana… but nearly every single project is completely separate from the other, serving a different municipality and being funded distinctly. This separation of the municipalities- thirty-four in all for Santiago- is fundamental and I believe a huuuuuge institutional challenge, one that is often overlooked by foreigners criticizing Santiago for lack of recycling.

Each comuna essentially has its own trash system, just as it generally has its own schools and hospitals. By and large it is the same with recycling, unless a separate, non-governmental entity (such as CODEFF) organizes a limited recycling program to raise funds. I was told that this system of decentralization was installed during the Pinochet regime… believable. As one can imagine the debates of inequality are rampant in Santiago; some municipalities such as Providencia and Santiago Centro have a larger tax base and are capable of spending many times more per resident than comunas such as La Pintana and Peñalolén, which have less income. Fact of the matter is, it is (~3x's) more costly to recycle a ton of trash at the Punto Limpio in Vitacura (a wealthier comuna) than it is to conventionally dispose of a ton of trash. The objective of the center is not economical, but rather exists for environmental and education benefits in one of the wealthier municipalities. This promulgates the cycle of disparity, as poorer comunas become less environmentally conscious (not to mention have inferior health and education systems). The bottom line is the recycling programs within the metropolitan region are not yet economically sustainable, even though the recycled materials can be sold to help make up for costs; it is still less expensive for the comunas to send recyclables to a landfill.

Part of the reason that the programs are so costly is that they are inefficient, and part of the reason that they are inefficient is that even people in the service area do not participate in the recycling program. Increased education and 100% participation would greatly increase the efficiency of the programs, but with sporadic participation a lot of manpower is used for collection and administration with relatively little results. Additionally, the programs sell the recycled materials to a buyer like Recupak, which makes all recycling programs that I am aware of dependent on the prices of materials, which vary and fluctuate. Waste is diverted from traditional modes of disposal which lowers that cost, but the combined earning and savings does not offset the costs of administering the public recycling programs. 
    
All thirty-four comunas are NOT in a position where they can spend resources on recycling, which would not have high public participation anyways, especially in its initiation.  Although the central government encourages recycling, it is difficult for municipalities to implement programs as it must come from within their budget. More creative initiatives… osea…programs developed keeping in mind characteristics and culture of Latin American and Santiago in particular, I believe have far greater potential than programs modeled on the US or Europe. Once a model proves promising and sustainable enough to at least become competitive with the costs of conventional waste disposal in the poorest of municipalities, it will eventually be possible to recycle in Santiago.